The score was composed by Chris Bacon and original theme composed by Danny Elfman.

The second season continued to use a large number of popular hits mixed with classical compositions in the soundtrack. The soundtrack includes “My Favorite Things” by the Lennon Sisters, “Un Mundo Raro” by Chavela Vargas, “Tropical Island” by Barry Lipman Singers, “Kiss Me” by Sixpence None the Richer, “Um Oh Ah Yey” by Mamamoo, Prokofiev’s Romeo and Juliet Op. 64, Act 1: Dance of the Knights, “No Time to Cry” by the Sisters of Mercy, “Nevermore Alma Mater” by Pitch Slaps, and “Dancing in the Dark” by Bruce Springsteen. Ortega was portrayed as performing Dance of the Knights on cello for an episode of season two. Lady Gaga released a new song for the second part of season two, titled “The Dead Dance”, in September 2025 which was featured in the seventh episode.